Sf Chronicle Review of Girls of the Golden West

The Girl of the Golden West

When a western beauty meets a dangerous brigand yous'll get a thrill at their hot-blooded romance!

Mary Robbins is a moderately educated, cute, immature adult female who owns the saloon called "The Poker". She is the only woman in the boondocks of Couldee - making her the fancy of all the men in that location, especially to Sheriff Jack Rance. On the style to Monterey to sing at a mass officiated by Father Sienna, her stagecoach is held up by the infamous masked bandit, Ramerez. He besides takes a fancy to Mary, and decides to secretly follow her, taking on the identity of an officer named, Lieutenant Johnson. While in Monterey, he dances, sings and courts Mary, who has now fallen in love with him. He then has to brand a quick getaway. In the mean-time, Sheriff Jack has set upwardly a trap to catch Ramerez at "The Poker". When Ramerez does arrive he soon discovers that Mary is the owner, and speedily changes to the identity of Lieutenant Johnson. How long tin this charade concluding?

Popular reviews

=============================
Wild West Summer Challenge 2021
=============================
Job #8 - Lookout man a Western with a stiff female graphic symbol

Orphaned teen Mary Robbins (Jeanne Ellis) joins her Uncle Davy (Charley Grapewin) on a carriage train spring for the gilded fields of California. They are about overcome by a gang of Mexican ground forces renegades, led by a human known as Ramirez the Full general (Noah Beery) and his adopted son, a white teenage orphan nicknamed Gringo (Neb Cody Jr.). Ramirez dies in the attack and Gringo takes his name to lead the gang to even greater mayhem as an adult (Nelson Eddy).

Fast forward a dozen or more than years. Uncle Davy has passed away and grown-up Mary (Jeanette MacDonald) is now the owner…
Like the other Jeanette MacDonald/Nelson Eddy motion-picture show I've seen (Rose-Marie), this pic really squeaks just past bad into mediocre because of some supporting performances, Boil and MacDonald's chemistry, and in "The Girl of the Gilt W" specifically, a remarkable performance past Jeanette MacDonald.

The outset is undoubtably worse than the stop, and as the movie continues, it does get better. But the get-go is but dreadful. Songs are cutting short (I'll talk more almost the songs in a moment) but the real effect is how racist this movie is. Racism confronting American Indians is pretty deeply baked into the genre of Westerns, and this motion picture actually had a few lines very slightly acknowledging that American Indians were provoked and attacked…
At least no ane had to eat their shoe
Mixed reviews I run across. How did I come up across the movie it was on Goggle box so I only saw office of it and I was like All correct it'due south too onetime-fashioned at this point why am I watching this when I don't bask it
A charming, textbook Singing Sweethearts musical, this time ready in the Old West, with tuneful saloon keeper Jeanette MacDonald unwittingly falling in honey with faux-Mexican brigand Nelson Eddy.

It's not as powerful or every bit fresh every bit Naughty Marietta, but there are great musical moments, and the film hits all the right notes in terms of emotion, with some suitably moving revelations buried beneath the surface, ready to detonate and practise impairment to your tear ducts.

At that place are besides pleasant supporting bits for Buddy Ebsen, Leo Carillo and the reliably fantabulous H. B. Warner, equally well as an attempt to replicate the success of Fred and Ginger'southward 'announce a dance craze' shenanigans, in the shape of a lavishly mounted Mariache number.…
This was earlier musicals had properly come of historic period, so both leads (Jeanette MacDonald and Nelson Eddy) chugalug out each musical number like they're performing in an opera house, using ridiculously high registers that come up off as stiff on screen and piercing to the ears. As a consequence none of the songs are much fun to sit through, but the story, characters, and actors all get by on amiable pluck, and oh man that wonderfully vintage B&W photography is a care for. Maybe I just don't watch enough B&Due west movies these days.

Extra credit to Walter Pidgeon for playing a damn fine Rhett Butler prototype - he's the forsaken member of the cadre love triangle, and yeah his rakish Sheriff Rance…
The singing western flick goes mainstream! With a grand MGM musical vehicle for Jeanette MacDonald and her screen sweetheart Nelson Eddy. Highly bogus and difficult to have a sophisticated lady like MacDonald as a simple western gal barely able to read. Perhaps fifty-fifty harder to take Eddy as the gringo bandit leader. Anyway, it's their standard formula in a new setting. Sadly not the right 1 for this pair. Nevertheless has the slick MGM style of moving-picture show making with Walter Pidgeon as the 3rd cycle and enough boosted characters to exist skillful fun even if this wasn't exactly a truthful western by heart.